11th Edition has finally landed, and after a handful of games, I’ve started to form some early impressions. As ever with a new edition of Warhammer 40k, there’s excitement, confusion, and the usual “wait… is that how it works now?” moments. Here’s how things are feeling so far.

Set-up time: longer, and not in a good way

The first thing that struck me is how much longer set-up feels in matched play. Without scenery templates, terrain placement becomes a faff. I’m honestly surprised these weren’t included in every starter set.

Top shot of a Warhammer 40k gaming table filled with various Imperial Ruins
Setting up still takes a lot of time
This site contains affiliate links you can use to support Tale of Painters. As Amazon Associates, eBay partners, and partners of our partner shops we earn from qualifying purchases. Thanks :)

A simple fix would be robust card templates in beginner sets and neoprene templates in premium sets.

You’d just drop your existing scenery onto clearly marked areas and get playing. No arguments, no guesswork, no “is this right placement?” drama. It feels like such an obvious quality-of-life improvement.

Force dispositions: confusing at first, but growing on me

I’ll admit it, Force Dispositions melted my brain initially. But after a few games, I’ve come around to them. They add a built-in narrative, asymmetry between players, and a break from rinse-and-repeat missions.

For me, each army having its own tailored primary objective improves the player experience. It feels more like a story unfolding rather than two forces racing to tick the same boxes. If a bit harder to remember as you are no longer playing the same missions.

More photos of Marneus Calgar and my Ultramarines here.

Shooting rules: still not sold on this…

Some of the new rule’s changes feel… odd. The one that’s tripping me up initially is the idea that you can’t shoot from the ground floor at a target more than 15″ away, even if you can clearly see it. Maybe I’ve misunderstood it, but it feels counterintuitive. If you can draw line of sight, you should be able to shoot. I’m hopeful that after a few more games this will settle in my mind, but right now it feels like a rule fighting against the cinematic nature of the game.

The 40k app is a win

As a self-confessed grey beard, I didn’t expect to enjoy using the app. But having everything instantly accessible is a positive, especially when you’re tired after a long day and trying to squeeze a game in.

Close-up of a game of Warhammer 40k, Ultramarines Brutalis Dreadnought and Chapter Ancient
Super handy in the midst of battle: the Warhammer 40k app

My eternal struggle with 40k: time

This has always been my biggest issue with 40k. It takes too long for casual, pick-up-and-play sessions. Garfy and I have talked about this for years. Mostly me ranting at him to be fair 😉

The challenge here is an obvious one: keep a wargame too simple, and it stops being interesting. Push it too far the other way, and it turns into more of a memory test than an actual game. Forgetting one rule can be punished hard in 40k. Sometimes it feels less like a game and more like an sweaty exam knightmare!

What about easy, medium, hard modes? With the “three ways to play” out, I was really hoping Games Workshop would introduce a new tiered mode this edition:

  • Easy Mode
    • Beer-and-pretzels
    • Core statlines
    • Basic shared stratagems
    • Quick games for newcomers or tired hobbyists
  • Medium Mode
    • More depth
    • More rules interactions
  • Hard Mode
    • “Full monty” competitive experience
    • Everything switched on: “GO TIME” for serious competitive players

In my view, this would make 40k far more accessible without diluting the competitive scene.

Dunk's cat Starbucks pouncing over a table of a Warhammer 40k game
Where is the datasheet for my super-heavy cat titan Starbucks?

11th Edition is exciting, frustrating, refreshing, and confusing all at once. There’s plenty I like, plenty I’m unsure about, and plenty I hope will click with more games. Have you had a chance to play yet? What do you think? Let me know in the comments below.